The Marshmallow Will See You Now

By  |  February 18, 2020 | 

This is the time of year to sit back at night, in front of the fireplace, a cup of hot chocolate in hand, warming up after the coolness of the day. As I sip, I notice the marshmallows bobbing up and down and reflect on the impact those white confections have in medicine. Yes, marshmallows have a medical history and stories that resonate for our daily work.

They’ve made their way into cereal, desserts, drinks. These sugary cubes infiltrate the day. And I now want them to infiltrate yours. Part of the doctor’s bag, as another tool to remind you of medicine’s history, teamwork and grit.

Turn on “Happier” by Marshmello for a few gooey stories about America’s favorite snack. Perhaps have a s’more, invented by the Girl Scouts, bounded by the graham cracker. A medicinal snack. The graham cracker, invented by Sylvester Graham, who started the dietary reform movement in the US. In the 1830s, he advocated for moderation and avoiding processed foods, which inspired a movement of Grahamites. The s’more centerpiece, the marshmallow, originated as an herbal remedy. The marsh-mallow root, known as Althaea officinalis, with Althaea derived from the Greek, meaning to heal. The root was used to make confections. Now all marshmallows are made with sugar and gelatin. This sticky root was carried in the old doctor’s bag as well. It has been used as a digestive cure, poultice and a cough suppressant. The chocolate bar flavoring contains the cocoa bean, another favorite medicinal.

As a kid, I loved taking the soft, cloud of goodness and mushing it over and over again, until it became a sticky mass a quarter its original size. The spongy lump of sugar turned into a sappy existence in a matter of seconds. Marshmallow transformation. A reminder of those daily transformative moments in the hospital, when a simple cough turns out to be a cancer diagnosis, or indigestion means a heart attack. When a moment becomes momentous. We live in those liminal moments – when things don’t always seem as they appear, and the world changes from the smooth to the sticky in a matter of seconds.

My kids tell me about their great projects in class. One of them involved dried spaghetti, tape, paperclips and a marshmallow. Whoever builds the tallest tower that can hold that marshmallow atop wins.  My kids have regaled tales of their tallest tower for years, but last year, reading about this in The Culture Code, I learned of the research done on this childhood challenge. Arts and crafts that teach us lessons about teamwork. Groups of kindergarteners were faced off against MBA students who had studied teamwork. Who would win? Who builds the tallest tower? The kindergarteners almost every time. Why?

Think about meetings and conversations you have in the hospital. I’ve seen near misses and errors, with folks afraid to discuss, share or present. I’ve been in QI meetings where we discuss the same problem for months. 6 months later, testing out a new order set. I’ve seen teams where interns and students are afraid to mention an unusual differential diagnosis. What about being on rounds where a nurse doesn’t mention to the provider about overnight events because of the deep-seated hierarchy?

The 5- and 6-year-olds aren’t afraid to speak up. There’s no hierarchy; they aren’t afraid of diving in and failing, then starting over. They aren’t planning the entire time. They aren’t holding back their suggestions because they fear the more experienced members of the team probably know the better answer. They speak up. Failing is tolerated and enjoyed, and no one puts their ego above the primary mission. The spaghetti tower. The patient.

The more famous marshmallow story involves grit, based on a 1983 Stanford study. If a marshmallow is placed in front of you to eat now, or if you are told you can have two if you wait 15 minutes, do you wait? Who waits for the better reward? Do you have the patience to sit for 30 more minutes to hear the full story and get a better diagnosis? We all made it through medical school, residency, grueling hours. I would say most folks in the medical profession delay gratification. Maintaining that grit, that perseverance will continue to get us through each tough day, avoid the shortcuts, to get through to the endgame. Though interesting, this study may not really live up to the 30-year hype. A 2018 study wasn’t able to reproduce the original study finding. Delaying gratification, grit, perseverance are still great traits, but the original study couldn’t be replicated. A reminder of the importance of replication in research.

These white nuggets floating around in the milky hot chocolate add an extra layer of smoothness to a wintry drink. They have been in the medicine bag from a long time. Now full of sugar instead of the root of the mellow plant. No longer a cure for stomach aches, though you can buy marshmallows with the original ingredients. Enjoy the transformative powers marshmallows bestow today: teamwork, grit, resilience, and well, they are perfect in that hot cocoa.

Leave A Comment

About the Author: Jordan Messler

Jordan Messler
Jordan Messler, MD is the Executive Director, Quality Initiatives at Glytec and works as a hospitalist at Morton Plant Hospitalist group in Clearwater, Florida. He previously chaired SHM’s Quality and Patient Safety Committee. In addition, he’s been active in several SHM mentoring programs, including Project BOOST and Glycemic Control. He went to medical school at University of South Florida, in Tampa and completed his residency at Emory University. He recognizes the challenges of working in a hospital that lines the intracostal waterways of a spring break mecca and requests that if you want to be selected as a mentored site, you will have a similar location with palm trees and coastline nearby. He tries to find time to sit on the beach with his family to escape the hospital’s miasma. While there, he looks forward to reading about the history of hospitals/medicine, and how it relates to quality. But inevitably, he will have his daughter dumping sand on him and then has to explain to his wife why their daughter is buried up to her neck.


Related Posts

By Robert A. Craven, MD, FHM, FACP
April 9, 2020 |  1
You may have seen the viral video going around on social media of my two daughters crying as I left my house earlier last week. My wife shared it on Facebook, and within a few days it had thousands of views, and various news media reached out to us for interviews. What we thought would […]
By Pooja Pundhir, MD, MPH
April 8, 2020 |  1
As healthcare professionals, we all concur that our nation has demonstrated considerable indolence in responding to the current global COVID-19 pandemic. First, it all started with our leaders adamantly denying any threat at all and an untimely response to institute stringent quarantine measures and provide adequate healthcare worker safety and ICU support. This was only […]
By Navneet Attri, MD
April 7, 2020 |  5
I am a hospitalist in a small community hospital in the San Francisco Bay Area. From our first COVID-19 patients off of the infamous Grand Princess Cruise ship – when we knew nothing about this dreaded virus – until now, our knowledge hasn’t made many meaningful strides. Most tools and treatment strategies are still in […]