Balancing Act

By  |  March 1, 2016 | 

My father died of Mantle cell lymphoma 12 years ago. He was only 60 when he succumbed, and despite being involved in the business and brouha of medicine literally since high school, I was so unprepared for his illness. It started when he came to visit me from his home in St. Louis.  He had a cold you see, and his cough after the cold was nagging and persistent.  I brought him over to my office and listened to him, looked in his ears, and gave him a course of antibiotics. A few weeks later he told me he thought his spleen was swollen and that he felt “full” after he ate. I told him to head to a doctor right away. He did, but was told he had “stress”. The following weekend I came to St. Louis, made him stretch out on the sofa. Yep. Giant spleen. This was followed by low platelets, biopsy, PET scan, lymphoma.

The diagnosis part wasn’t so bad. I mean if you have been in healthcare any length of time you have what I refer to as “cancer paranoia”-aware, always aware, of the precious disease free hours of life. The treament was rough. Watching my vigorous, lady-loving, businessman father depart from golf, and cabernet for frailty, unsteadiness and fear was hard. It was hard to see.

For a while he had a remission, and made jokes about how the family was putting yellow sticky notes on all his possessions in anticipation of his untimely passing.  It was a good time, but cancer takes away that unbridled happiness, and leaves a bittersweet taste.  I watched him watch my three year old on the carousel thinking, “Is this the last time he will see this?”  It despoils every aspect of joy, but at the same time, makes it more poignant.  I read a story about a woman who had metastatic colon cancer and three little kids.  She said life with cancer is just like regular life, but you have more pancakes. Would I have really noticed that carousel moment without the specter of cancer hanging pall over everything? Pass the pancakes.

Ultimately he contracted a horrible bilateral bilobar pneumonia. He was in ICU on 100% oxygen, delerious for days. Although the decision to withdraw care seems obvious now, at the time it was the elephant in the room that no one would acknowledge. But when I look back on this time there are two events that stand at the front of this experience-twin soldiers standing on either side of this – bookends of bad and good.

In the daytime, my father’s delerium would ease, and what he wanted more than anything was a glass of orange juice.  He had been NPO due to his respiratory status. I asked the nurse if he could just have a little juice. She said no. I asked could I please speak with the resident about this. She went away and came back and said, “The resident says he is not going to talk with you about the orange juice.” I was very angry-not about the orange juice per se,  but about the seemingly callous refusal to even speak with me. It seemed to reflect what everyone who was caring for my father was demonstrating to me: disinterest,  disengagement,  immunity to all our pain and sadness.

At night the delerium was naturally worse so we took turns being up all night with him in the ICU, keeping the oxygen on, stopping him from climbing out of bed or pulling out IVs.  Such a long, endless night of cold cloths, and holding urinals and putting the oxygen back on and covering him up and uncovering him only to repeat that sequence again. And again. At 5am, my shift was over, and I was glad. I couldn’t do it anymore. I could not stop my heart from breaking anymore. I could not be strong anymore. And as I walked out of the ICU-an ICU nurse-an angel-saw me, gave me such a complete look of compassion and then simply hugged me for a long moment while I wept a little.  She kept saying, “It’s so hard, it’s so hard.” And it was.  But that hug, that compassion helped a lot. It gave me the lift I needed to keep breathing in and out, to keep putting one foot in front of the other, to survive the pain.

Ultimately my father came home with hospice, and his passing was peaceful, and meaningful with family at his side.

As providers it is clear, we cannot always live in the land of compassion. We cannot always want to give patients orange juice when it’s not good for them.  We have to have some clinical objectivity or we would never leave the hospital, we would melt the cell walls of our existence and be very ineffective clinicians indeed.

But the outcome for my father would be unchanged regardless-and that compassion, so freely and generously given to me, did help make that journey survivable.

I think we can’t be completely subsumed with compassion-feeling other’s pain as if it is our own.  In my own experience it is sometimes hard to feel any at times.   And frequently the opposite is true; that it is hard to keep from feeling too much.  I sometimes have to remind myself-this is not your father/uncle/mother/brother/sister/child.  This is not about you.

What we need is balance.  The balance of humanity, compassion and understanding, but with thought and objectivity.

One Comment

  1. Avatar
    Irene S. Klotz, LMSW, CPT March 1, 2016 at 9:11 am - Reply

    For Tracy – what an amazing piece of writing! You got the humanity, the compassion, the understanding, the thoughtfulness, the objectivity. You got it all right, just perfectly. But most of all by talking about your personal experience, you conveyed the necessary balance that as providers we need to keep at the fore. I have a private practice of medical counseling/health and wellness coaching – I call it “KeepingLifeBalanced.” I hope I convey that balance as well as you have. Thank you.

Leave A Comment

About the Author: Tracy Cardin

Tracy Cardin
Tracy Cardin, ACNP-BC, SFHM is currently the Vice President, Advanced Practice Providers, at Sound Physicians and serves on SHM’s Board of Directors as its secretary. Prior to this, she was the Associate Director of Clinical Integration at Adfinitas Health, the Director of NP/PA Services for the University of Chicago and worked in private practice for a group of excellent pulmonologists/intensivists for over a decade. She has been a member of SHM for over ten years and has over twenty years of inpatient experience, which seems incredible as she cannot possibly be that old! Her interests include integration of NP/PA providers into hospital medicine groups and communication in difficult situations. In her free time, she likes to run and lift, read and write and hang out on the front porch of her semi-restored Victorian house with her dear family and friends while drinking a fine glass of red wine and listening to whatever music suits her whimsy.


Related Posts

February 20, 2018 |  6
“We Need Creative Solutions” When I read or hear the sentence above, I think of one thing and one thing only. The solution is long in coming, involves input from multiple parties, has no obvious fix, is costly–in either money or time, and we undergird it by a whopper of a collective action problem. How […]
October 2, 2017 |  0
Last week I was in Dunkin’ Donuts and noticed something odd—although the oddness did not strike me immediately.  The woman who was serving me could have been my grandmother. Ditto that when I was at Home Depot in the lighting aisle yesterday.  And ditto it again in Walmart this morning. I would never dream of […]
September 11, 2017 |  0
You all think you know hospice. You don’t, and I will tell you why. Hospice is a bastard child of the Medicare system. It went live in 1983 as a standalone entity during the Reagan administration and remains a disjointed program today. I would characterize its evolution as such: the road to hell is paved with good intentions. […]