The Nation’s Top Doctor: A Hospitalist

By  |  March 18, 2014 | 

Last month, Dr. Vivek Murthy was confirmed by the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee for the nation’s top post as a physician – Surgeon General. The full Senate will now ultimately schedule a vote on his nomination. It is noteworthy in a number of ways, such as being the youngest Surgeon General or the first South Asian to be nominated for this office. However, there is another way in which his nomination is noteworthy – he is also a hospitalist.  In fact, while practicing as a hospitalist at the Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Dr. Murthy was able lead advocacy and community organizing initiatives through Doctors for America, which was a major vehicle to help doctors advocate for expanding insurance for all through the Affordable Care Act.

While his advocacy to promote better health and access to care through Doctors for America has been seen by Republicans as “too political,” it’s important to remember that doctors are often accused of being too passive and not having an active voice in healthcare policy decisions. Perhaps that is one reason that the Office of the Surgeon General is often seen an irrelevant post. I hope that Dr. Murthy has the opportunity to fix that.

He has also been accused of being a “radical” for suggesting that curbing gun violence is a “public health issue.”  Let’s be clear.  His positions are in line with numerous professional societies, including the American Public Health Association (APHA). Gun violence results in 30,000 deaths and 60,000 non-fatal injuries per year, which makes it a public health issue. The APHA actually states that gun violence can be “prevented through a comprehensive public health approach that keeps families and communities safe.”

Perhaps the most ridiculous criticism that I saw of Dr. Murthy was that he does not deserve the position because he has not been “anyone’s doctor” because he is a hospitalist and does not have a clinic where he followed patients.  Of course, this is likely partisan muckraking and very outdated thinking, recognized by a great tweet by Bob Wachter. However, it does not dismiss the fact that hospitalists sometimes come under fire for not having a panel of patients they care for in clinic.

While hospitalists may not practice in clinic, however, it does not mean they are not serving as “anyone’s doctor.” I was just finishing service and reflecting on what hospitalist do… Certainly, they care for a complex set of patients who need intensely coordinated acute care among a variety of specialists. I found myself having difficult family meetings discussing long-term prognosis of manifestations of chronic disease, counseling asthma patients on the perils of continued smoking and offering assistance to quit, choosing pain medications a patient can afford, or reviewing reams of lab data along with physical exam and history data to put together a rare diagnosis.

While it is true that hospitalists as a group do not develop long-term relationships with their patients, hospitalists still serve as “someone’s doctor” and guide their patients at the most acutely ill time of their life when they are in an unfamiliar and all-too-often uncomfortable environment. While I may never see my patient again after they are discharged, it does not mean that I never do. Occasionally, I have seen my former patients in the community or going to their clinic appointments and they remember me and provide me with some insight into how important I, their doctor, was to them. I took care of a patient who recognized me in the hallway a year later when his wife was hospitalized and said, “Doc you saved my life, thank you!” I am not even mentioning the very important subset of patients who must use the hospital as their principal site of care, and are more familiar to the hospital physician than to their primary care physician, if they even have one or can get into see them.

Caring for patients takes a village, and one part of that village is being in the hospital where patients will certainly meet many types of doctors, including a hospitalist who will be in charge of their care. Dr. Vivek Murthy is a hospitalist, is someone’s doctor, a public health advocate, and is more than qualified for serving as the Surgeon General.

One Comment

  1. Brad Flansbaum
    Brad Flansbaum March 18, 2014 at 12:30 pm - Reply

    Amen Vin, and thanks for stating the obvious.

    Using the ill-conceived logic of “hospital docs” dont qualify, perhaps we can extend the same to “MD’s shouldnt lead companies,” or even “college dropouts shouldnt go into business.” You know, cause titles matter and whats in the heart and soul dont count.

    I am appalled at how the nomination process is playing out. I hope cooler heads prevail and both Vivek and the country get what they deserve: a noble position and an exceptionally qualified candidate respectively.


Leave A Comment

About the Author: Vineet Arora

Vineet Arora MD, MPP is Director of GME Clinical Learning Environment and Assistant Dean for Scholarship and Discovery at the University of Chicago Pritzker School of Medicine. Dr. Arora’s scholarly work has focused on resident duty hours, patient handoffs, sleep, and quality and safety of hospital care. She is the recipient of the SHM Excellence in Hospital Medicine Research Award in 2007. Her work has appeared in numerous journals, including JAMA and the Annals of Internal Medicine, and has received coverage from the New York Times, CNN, and US News & World Report. She was selected as ACP Hospitalist Magazine’s Top Hospitalist in 2009 and by HealthLeaders Magazine as one of 20 who make healthcare better in 2011. She has testified to the Institute of Medicine on resident duty hours and to Congress about increasing medical student debt and the primary care crisis. As an academic hospitalist, she supervises medical residents and students caring for hospitalized patients. Dr. Arora is an avid social media user, and serves as Deputy Social Media Editor to the Jounral of Hospital Medicine, helping to maintain its Twitter feed and Facebook presence. She blogs about her experiences at and actively tweets at @futuredocs.


Related Posts

By  | October 16, 2018 |  0
By: Rich Bottner, PA-C and Victoria Valencia, MPH You submit an issue to your Event Reporting System and never hear back. You discuss the need for institutional improvement with your colleagues around the water cooler, but few things seem to change. Sound familiar? Instead of passively waiting for quality improvement to happen in hospitals, organizations […]
By  | October 2, 2018 |  0
On behalf of SHM’s Practice Analysis Committee, I’m delighted to announce that the 2018 State of Hospital Medicine Report is now available! This year’s report may be the most representative yet regarding the current state of hospital medicine. Of the survey’s 569 respondent groups: 52% are employed by hospitals or health systems 25% are employed […]
By  | September 27, 2018 |  0
This article originally appeared on the Josiah Macy Jr. Foundation website. While I was waiting in the pre-op area for a medical procedure, the anesthesiologist entered the room and introduced himself to me.  After asking me about my surgical and anesthesiology history, he asked about my allergies. I reported my allergy to a blue food […]